It has been two years since Thomas Bertrand-Hudon, a running back for the Saskatchewan Roughriders, made history as the first CFL player to don a Guardian Cap on his helmet during a game.
Although these protective soft shells are now mandatory for various positions during practices to lessen the impact from hits and tackles, they have yet to gain traction in actual games within the Canadian professional league.
The trend is similarly lacking in high school and youth football leagues.
Emerson, the son of Derek Hogelie, is currently the sole player on his Regina high school football team who wears a Guardian Cap during games.
Hogelie admitted that his decision was driven by personal concern. As a parent, he wanted to ensure his son’s safety, and persuading Emerson to adopt the same mindset was not difficult.
“He idolizes numerous NFL players, and he’s noticed that many of them are sporting these caps—though more often in practice than in games. So, it wasn’t a hard sell to get him on board with it. He was completely supportive,” Hogelie shared with CBC Saskatchewan’s Blue Sky.
Though the distinctive, padded appearance of the caps can make them less appealing, particularly if no one else is wearing them, Hogelie emphasized that safety was the priority for both him and his son.
“Our bodies are equipped with backups, like two arms and two legs, but we only have one brain. That was the main factor. If we can spend a fraction of what we paid for the helmet to provide an extra layer of protection, why wouldn’t we?” Hogelie remarked.

Guardian Caps are required for the Saskatchewan Selects football team in both practices and games to ensure player safety. (saskselectsfb/Instagram)
After implementing mandatory use of the caps for offensive and defensive linemen, running backs, and linebackers during practices and training camps, the CFL discovered a 42 percent reduction in concussions during the 2023 training camp.
Bertrand-Hudon expressed to Blue Sky host Jennifer Quesnel that he felt a noticeable difference while using the soft shell.
“I sense that the initial impact from blunt force is less jarring when I have it on,” Bertrand-Hudon stated.
- Concussion experts advocate for CFL players to use Guardian Caps, stressing athletes should not feel ‘invincible’
- Guardian Caps, a soft-shell helmet cover, are part of CFL’s new player-safety measures
Reducing injury risks
One youth football program has mandated the use of caps for all players, both in practices and games.
The Saskatchewan Selects Football Club enforced the use of Guardian Caps three years ago.
“As an off-season developmental program, our priority is to minimize any potential injuries for the kids,” stated Zeljko Stefanovic, director of the Saskatchewan Selects, during an interview with CBC Saskatchewan’s Blue Sky.

Zeljko Stefanovic, director of the Saskatchewan Selects, emphasizes the importance of safety, particularly since the Selects serve as a development program for players looking to enhance their skills. (saskselectsfb/Instagram)
Stefanovic’s safety measures extend beyond just headgear.
He collaborates with Patrick Neary, a professor specializing in concussions within the kinesiology and health studies department at the University of Regina, to ensure optimal safety for his football team.
“Zeljko has visited my office numerous times, expressing his concerns for his players,” Neary mentioned to CBC Saskatchewan’s Blue Sky.
Stefanovic is adopting a comprehensive strategy for concussion and head injury prevention. Guided by Neary, he instructs his players on safe tackling techniques and discourages leading with their heads, aiming to protect their brains.
“While my evidence is anecdotal, we have observed a decline in the number of reported concussions during our games,” Stefanovic noted.
He mentioned receiving feedback from other coaches regarding the soft shells, but primarily, the caps are influencing other development programs seeking to enhance player safety.

Stefanovic reports that other coaches and parents have inquired about Guardian Caps, though they have not yet gained widespread acceptance among other teams. (saskselectsfb/Instagram)
According to Neary, the limited information and studies demonstrating the efficacy of Guardian Caps may explain why these soft shells have not become prevalent in more minor league football teams.
“This is relatively new research, and we are just beginning to uncover more details about it,” Neary explained.

